Nicolo’s serves a solid standard pie, cut in squares and served with the cheese covering the high quality toppings. Owner is very nice and inviting. Wings are average, baked-in-the-pizza-oven wings, so can’t recommend. Otherwise, - good family-run establishment 👍🏼
Steve Hustler
-
June 04, 2022
4.5 🌟 I was worried cuz of the recent bad reviews! But I had great friendly service and experience. The garlic bread was tasty! Great marinara sauce definitely not canned 🥫 I got the vino calzone and it was great! Italian sausage had good flavor and bread was cooked great.
RO Med
-
April 26, 2023
Had high hopes for this place but unfortunately the calzone I ordered was a huge disappointment. I’m fine with a place charging $15 for a calzone but at least use ingredients that warrant that. The pineapple was dripping almost as if they just opened a new can. And they added only one slice of Canadian bacon.
Trin (Glamrocklizardman)
-
February 15, 2023
To be completely transparent I work here so I am a bit biased but I love you our menu we have great options for Vegetarian and the best Gluten Free crust I've ever had. The atmosphere is lovely and we treat each other like family. We introduce new specials each week, and make a great majority of the menu completely from scratch.
Chad Willy
-
February 25, 2023
My girlfriend is sensitive to dairy. She told the server and ordered build your own pasta "without any dairy please." The server didn't tell her that the spicy marinara was creme based on the fettucinne and meatballs. My girlfriend knew right away that her pasta had creme in the sauce and verified with the server. Luckily, she ordered meatballs too and asked for a side of marinara to dip the meatballs in since she wasn't going to be able to eat the creamy marinara.
The server promptly brought her a side of marinara, but it had grated parmesean cheese on top of it. At this point, my girlfriend was fed up with the inattentiveness of the server and just gave up. She only had a few bites of the meatballs and left the rest for me.
One other issue was that I ordered an iced tea at the beginning, and midway through the meal, the server took it to refill it but never returned with it.
Nicolo’s serves a solid standard pie, cut in squares and served with the cheese covering the high quality toppings. Owner is very nice and inviting. Wings are average, baked-in-the-pizza-oven wings, so can’t recommend. Otherwise, - good family-run establishment 👍🏼
4.5 🌟 I was worried cuz of the recent bad reviews! But I had great friendly service and experience. The garlic bread was tasty! Great marinara sauce definitely not canned 🥫 I got the vino calzone and it was great! Italian sausage had good flavor and bread was cooked great.
Had high hopes for this place but unfortunately the calzone I ordered was a huge disappointment. I’m fine with a place charging $15 for a calzone but at least use ingredients that warrant that. The pineapple was dripping almost as if they just opened a new can. And they added only one slice of Canadian bacon.
To be completely transparent I work here so I am a bit biased but I love you our menu we have great options for Vegetarian and the best Gluten Free crust I've ever had. The atmosphere is lovely and we treat each other like family. We introduce new specials each week, and make a great majority of the menu completely from scratch.
My girlfriend is sensitive to dairy. She told the server and ordered build your own pasta "without any dairy please." The server didn't tell her that the spicy marinara was creme based on the fettucinne and meatballs. My girlfriend knew right away that her pasta had creme in the sauce and verified with the server. Luckily, she ordered meatballs too and asked for a side of marinara to dip the meatballs in since she wasn't going to be able to eat the creamy marinara. The server promptly brought her a side of marinara, but it had grated parmesean cheese on top of it. At this point, my girlfriend was fed up with the inattentiveness of the server and just gave up. She only had a few bites of the meatballs and left the rest for me. One other issue was that I ordered an iced tea at the beginning, and midway through the meal, the server took it to refill it but never returned with it.